Not content with just revolutionizing our knowledge of Pluto, New Horizons is still cruising, and exploring more of the outer solar system. Its first close flyby after Pluto is with the Kuiper belt object (KBO) named '2014 MU69', aka Ultima Thule. Ultima is far smaller than Pluto: about 30 km across rather than 2400 -- making it perhaps one one-millionth the mass of Pluto. And it is colder, slower, and more primitive, and by far the smallest body in the outer solar system we've ever flown past.
New Horizons' nominal job is to fly a pre-programmed path past the body, and execute a pre-set sequence of observations. We'll get the vast majority of our data from within the central hour of our flyby. The spacecraft is moving at some 15 km/sec (52,000 kph).
At the speed that we're traveling, a millimeter-sized dust grain could end the mission. And, while space itself (the 'interplanetary medium') is pretty empty, the region around the planets is not. For all we know, MU69 could have moons, rings, or a cloud of dust around it. Other planets, asteroids, and comets often do, so it's plausible that MU69 could.
It was hard enough to detect MU69 itself with the Hubble Space Telescope in 2014 when it was discovered, and it's essentially impossible to use Hubble to probe thoroughly for dust near MU69. The target is just too faint, too small, and too far away.
Enter the New Horizons Hazard Team! Our job was to keep the spacecraft safe at encounter, by assessing the impact risk from dust as we were closing in. The result of our work was a binary decision: do we fly the spacecraft on its ideal 'prime' trajectory that goes just 3500 km above the surface, or do we take a backup 'alternate' trajectory that is 10,000 km away?
After 18 months of telecons and planning, we got to work on December 1, 2018, a month before encounter. By this point New Horizons' image of MU69 were becoming good enough that we could start to resolve structure in the system. (The images were far better at this point than what we had gotten from Hubble: HST is much larger, but further away.) We were far from seeing any detail on the body itself, but if there were very large, very bright clouds of dust thousands of km across, then even our initial surveys on December 1 would see them. And as we closed in, our scale got much better, to the point where we could resolve rings or clouds on the 100-km scale (and moons far smaller than that). These images would inform our decision over which trajectory to recommend.
The Hazard Team is comprised of a dozen people:
For 17 days we worked in a single room together at the Johns Hopkins Applied Physics Lab (APL), outside Laurel, MD. The culmination of this work was a decision made with the spacecraft 'stakeholders' (i.e., PI Alan Stern, managers, and engineers), where they chose whether to fly the Prime trajectory, or the Alternate.
In the end we found: absolutely nothing! No moons, no rings, no clouds of dust, down to our limit of detectability (for moons, 1.4 km assuming albedo = 0.09 outward of 1000 km; for rings and dust, I/F < 5e-7). Furthermore, we identified no stable orbits that dust even could theoretically survive for long times at MU69. We were confident that, with the data we had, the MU69 system looked clear, and we recommended the mission fly the Prime trajectory.
Thanks much to Carl Engelbrecht and Alan Stern for arranging to allow photography on the lab. This was a rare privilege and I'm grateful we were able to document the preparations for this historic flyby. Credit also to Mark Showalter who led us in the crow's nest this whole time.
Photo credits: NASA / JHUAPL / SwRI / Henry Throop, with a few by NASA / JHUAPL / SwRI / John Spencer, as noted.
|
| Hal Weaver and Adriana Ocampo at the Science Team Meeting. |
|
| Joel Parker tells me about his son's Fulbright-funded adventures teaching in Omsk, Siberia. |
|
| Dan Britt. |
|
| New Horizons may be powered by plutonium, but it's taken a lot more than 11 kg of bananas to get us all the way there. |
|
| Lisa Turner is making a list. Zoom in and you can see she's just added my name. I wonder what for! |
|
| Mark Showalter kicks off the TCM Divert Decision Meeting rehearsal. We had rehearsals for everything, including meetings. |
|
| John Spencer walks through a practice of various spacecraft scenarios he's dreamed up, which might cause us to consider diverting to the alternate path. |
|
| John Spencer, with Carl Engelbrecht behind. Not too many photos of Carl, but he was a big part of our happiness at APL. |
|
| APL Project Manager Helene Winters stops by. Amanda: "Check out this article that just came out on CNN... it's about the Senegal occultation trip, and it's by Salma Mbaye, who we observed with. Oh, she was so cool -- she was the first PhD astronomy student ever in Senegal." |
|
| Hal Weaver, Glen Fountain, Adriana Ocampo, and Alan Stern. |
|
|
|
|
|
| Mission Operations Manager Alice Bowman, at the divert decision run-through. |
|
| Chris Hersman debates over whether to take the Prime or Alternate trajectory. |
|
|
|
| And we've chosen to remain on the Prime trajectory, at least for this rehearsal. This surprised John, who thought that at least one of his scenarios would be bad enough to fly the Alternate. |
|
|
|
| Simon Porter can do anything. As Will Grundy said a few months ago: "Yeah, my role here is to be a second-rate backup for Simon, basically. Frankly, I think we're all second-rate backups for Simon." |
|
| Marc Buie. |
|
| Mark Showalter, Doug Hamilton, and David Kaufmann. Behind them is the signed flag from the summer 2017 MU69 occultation campaign to Comodoro, Argentina. We're at K-31d. |
|
| Derek Nelson, center, is the head of New Horizons OpNav at KinetX. |
|
| John, Marc, Simon, and John look at debris in the way at the primary orbit (inner circle). But no -- it's just stars. |
|
| Check out that bright MU69! |
|
| Amanda has decorated our tree with a scientifically correct, heart-filled Pluto. |
|
| Hal Weaver checks out some of Marc Buie's flattened image stacks (center bottom) and radial profiles (two white plots). |
|
| Alan Stern, Mike Buckley, and Cindy Conrad talk about media plans for encounter. |
|
|
|
| Mark Showalter celebrates his birthday by running a telecon and talking about dust trajectories! |
|
| Thomas Mehoke and Doug Mehoke! |
|
| Hazard team takes the evening off for some Maryland crabs. Cindy is a big crab afficionado and we are lucky to have her showing us the true path! |
|
| Check out those crabs! 18 there, and another 18 at the other end of the table. |
|
| Doug Hamilton and Cindy Conrad take the first step. |
|
| Derek Nelson and Mark Showalter, mid-crab. |
|
| Hal Weaver and Leslie Young. |
|
| Field trip! The hazard team went to watch Bohemian Rhapsody. Queen guitarist Brian May worked with the mission for a couple of days at the 2015 Pluto encounter. (Yes, he does have a PhD in astronomy -- and no, he didn't bring his guitar.) He's already put together a song and video for MU69: Brian May to Release First Solo Single in 20 Years from NASA Control Room: New Horizons. The movie is great, and we love Brian. From left: that's John Spencer, Mark Showalter, Tod Lauer, Amanda Zangari, Anne Verbiscer, David Kaufmann, Cindy Conrad, Derek Nelson, Joel Fischetti, and Michael Salinas. |
|
| Behind APL is the subdivision of Maple Lawn; to the left is a legitimate agricultural operation. |
|
| Morning fog walking to the lab! |
|
| Light and crane from the new building, seen from the trees next door. |
|
| Simon, Amanda, and Anne -- all veterans of multiple MU69 occultation campaigns -- give Marc input on fits to the light curves and occultation data. |
|
| Simon Porter with his latest image stack. Blue is the background level, roughly 0 DN +- 1e-6. White are masked stars, and the red lines are sunflower orbits around MU69. |
|
| Thomas Mehoke. Thomas and his father Doug Mehoke did the final steps in the hazard analysis, which involved computing the actual damage to the spacecraft given a certain impator flux. |
|
| Marc and the group talk about PSFs. |
|
|
|
| Doug Mehoke gets the entire hazard team up to speed on damage probabilities. |
|
| Amanda Zangari really wants to plot your light curves and astrometry! |
|
| John Spencer and Tod Lauer. |
|
| Chris Hersman in the fashionable red tie. |
|
| Alan: "I tell you what... let's do the Ultima Thule symbol. It's really easy... it's a U and a T. Some guy on Facebook showed it to me." |
|
| Chris Hersman comes up with something. I don't know what it is, but it's not MU69, or Pluto. Guess we gotta find a new target! |
|
| Marc Buie and Will Grundy. |
|
| Marc Buie's computer, with his three competing shape models. |
|
| Mark Showalter: "So, they were just disposing of books downstairs. I saw this and had to get it. Read up, everyone!" |
|
| Will Grundy is putting together light curves. |
|
| Anne updates the distance... 0.14 AU and dropping fast! And yes, Bohemian Rhapsody lyrics below. |
|
| As our time comes to an end, the snacks do keep on coming! |
|
| Amanda signs our awesome team portrait, by Tod's daughter Sandra Muller |
|
| Check out that tri-lobed spheroid! |
|
| John Spencer hasn't found any rings yet, so it's time to optimize that shape model! |
|
| Mark Showalter and Doug Hamilton. |
|
| Tod: "Will... your fancy 3D model might be right. But you know what else matches that light curve precisely? A rapidly spinning rotisserie chicken. Otherwise known as... Ultima Poulet!" |
|
|
|
| Alice Bowman. |
|
| Leslie Young. |
|
| Will Grundy is almost as festive as our tree. |
|
| Mark Holdridge. |
|
| And he's off! Mark Showalter starts the final presentation. |
|
| All of our results, executively summarized. |
|
| John Spencer documents. |
|
| Leslie Young asks about moons. |
|
| Alan Stern is really excited! |
|
| And by unanimous agreement of the 'Stakeholders' (i.e., mission management and engineers), as well as the Hazard team, we've declared the MU69 system safe! |
|
| Alice Bowman and Hal Weaver are breathing more easily now. Photo by John Spencer. |
|
| Mark Showalter has emerged victorious over the dust particles! Photo by John Spencer. |
|
| Keeping space safe! |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Last modified 11 Jun 2023